Cotton Mattress

Jessica Zernike | Feb 10, 2021

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more >

Don't you think that the best mattresses are those that let you sleep even more peacefully by getting rid of any sort of worries? Perhaps that's why we have a soft spot for cotton mattresses!

Natural and breathable, they keep you safe from any type of allergens. This means that you don't have to worry about plastic-derived materials ending up in direct contact with your skin for hours every single night.

When choosing a cotton mattress, the most important thing to consider is probably the level of firmness that you require. This depends on a mixture of personal preference and health recommendations, like your BMI (body mass index).

A soft mattress is usually the best choice if you sleep on the side and your BMI is below average.

A medium option is a fantastic compromise if you and your partner have different firmness requirements. It's also handy for back sleepers and for people with an average BMI.

Finally, firmer mattresses are the safest choice for stomach sleepers and those with a BMI that's above average.

Another thing that you might want to consider is the type of mattress core.

Innerspring is still the most popular option. It's breathable and offers a good amount of bounce as well as the widest firmness range.

Memory foam is famous for its slow-reacting feel, with the mattress compressing under your body weight.

Latex is a bouncier option, usually most comfortable for people who prefer firmer mattresses.

To avoid unpleasant surprises, we also recommend measuring your bed and the exact size of your current mattress.

Oliver Smith - Organic Cotton - 10 Inch - Perfect Sleep - Comfort Plush Euro Pillow Top - Cool Memory Foam & Pocket Spring Mattress - Green Foam Certified - King

This cotton mattress is one of the most natural options out there. Relying on an organic ventilated cooling cover and a green-foam-certified filling, it’s soft, breathable and safe. It even includes a euro pillow top for enhanced comfort. Thanks to its reliable features, we especially recommend it to people with back issues.

Naturepedic Organic Cotton Quilted Deluxe 2-Sided Mattress - Full - 53" x 75" x 10"

Relying on a premium orthopedic innerspring construction with border wire, this luxurious choice consists of US-grown organic cotton. Say bye to polyurethane foam or latex! From their impressive attention to detail to the use of premium materials, no wonder this cotton model is made by the most awarded organic mattress company.

Best 2 Rest 10 inch Natural Latex Foam Mattress Queen with Organic Cotton Cover – 10 Year Warranty - CertiPUR-US Certified – Made in USA

This queen-sized cotton mattress is a clever hybrid model that can work wonders for couples with different preferences. In fact, it involves both natural latex foam and an organic cotton cover, entirely US-made. The result is a breathable mattress that’s also dust mite- and allergy-proof.

My Green Mattress - Pure Echo GOTS Certified Organic Cotton Natural Mattress (One-Sided) (Twin) Made in The USA

Certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard, this twin cotton mattress is a safe and breathable choice for smaller beds. It offers a versatile medium firmness thanks to its innerspring construction and it even involves a premium filling of natural Joma wool from New Zealand.

Oliver Smith - Organic Cotton - 10 Inch - Comfort Firm Sleep - Cool Memory Foam & Pocket Spring Mattress - Green Foam Certified - Full

Available in every conceivable size, this cotton mattress is a godsend for people with back issues. It hides 15-gauge pocket coils to enhance its softness while maintaining a medium-firm feel. Consisting of an organic cotton cover and a ventilated 100% Green Foam-certified filling, it’s a superb choice if you’re striving for a mattress that’s entirely natural.

Hypoallergenic and featuring medium firmness, this cotton mattress is perfect for couples: because it isolates any motion from a restless sleeping partner, it’ll prevent any future arguments in the middle of the night. The natural cotton and latex design of this hybrid model is also perfect to avoid the quicksand feel of similar memory foam options.

Soft and hypoallergenic, this premium cotton mattress is ideal for vegans as it doesn’t involve any kind of wool. It also features cooling technology and stretch-certified organic cotton. From the smallest twin option to the widest California king, this mattress is available in more sizes than you could hope for.

Certified Organic 10" Firm Innerspring Mattress

This Greenguard-certified cotton mattress guarantees the most comfortable sleep. Not only is it rather firm and features the coveted low motion transfer: it also relies on a special layer of micro coils (on top of some premium encased coils) to help relieve pressure points.

Cool Bliss 12" Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress

This medium-firm cotton mattress is available in many different sizes and it’s a fantastic breathable option. Thanks to its gel-based memory foam, it dissipates moisture and heat three times faster than traditional models, making it cooler and more pleasant to sleep in. It also involves a premium level of natural latex.

We weren’t surprised to find out that this hybrid model was voted #1 best latex mattress by customers! After all, in only relies on the highest-quality natural materials. The filling is made of ARPICO latex (the world’s finest type) and 100% natural Joma wool. The cotton cover doesn’t disappoint either: GOTS-certified, it’s soft and free from unhealthy chemicals.